Dave’s Cat’s Meow
Pros: All varieties are under 5% carbohydrates; BPS free; Manufactured in USA and Canada
Cons: Some varieties are high in fat; some varieties include fruits and vegetables
Dave’s Naturally Healthy
Pros: Pates are under 5% carbohydrates; BPS free; Manufactured in USA and Canada; available in 12.5 ounce cans
Cons: Some varieties include fruits and vegetables; the gravy version is over 10% carbohydrate
Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals
Pros: The varieties we recommend have 0% carbohydrates; Ingredients are from USA and Canada
Cons: Pea Protein, Tapioca starch, not all varieties are equally good
I And Love And You
Pros: BPA and GMO-free; ingredients sourced in USA and Canada and premium proteins sourced from New Zealand, Australia, and Brazil
Cons: Calcium and phosphorous levels in the chicken and rabbit varieties are at the high end of the normal range.
Identity 95%
Pros: GMO-free meat sourced from Canadian and New Zealand farms.
Cons: The carbohydrate percentage can go up to 10% in some varieties.
Rawz
Pros: BPA and Gum-free
Cons: Includes Dandelion greens, Fenugreek seeds, and vegetable broth
Tiki Cat After Dark
Pros: BPA-Free; often available at local pet stores; ingredients sourced from New Zealand.
Cons: Supply chain combined with popularity has caused shortages; some varieties are higher than 10% carbohydrate.